Why I Dumped My USPS PO Box for a Virtual Mailbox with Anytime Mailbox

Unless you've been buried in the sand the last few months, you know the importance of having a plan B, C, and D. While I don't believe you can plan for every possible disaster, you can mitigate the stress by making decisions now that your future self will thank you for later. After removing social media, I decided to look hard at what was working and what was wasting time and money. I had to revise my tech stack and business operations to adapt to political and market changes. It started by replacing my USPS PO Box for a Virtual Mailbox with an Anytime Mailbox.

The USPS PO Box That Couldn't

When I first got my USPS PO Box in 2016, I mainly used it for a now-defunct e-commerce travel clothing and accessories shop to avoid giving my physical address for email marketing purposes. Unfortunately, that only worked for receiving and sending mail and packages, and I couldn't legally use it as a business mailing address. That meant that I was doxxing myself, and to this day, I continue to receive mail for that business at home.

It didn't stop there.

Right around the lockdown of 2020, our post office lobby was vandalized twice. My mailbox was spared the first time, but they busted the lock beyond recognition the second time. I received a letter from the post office asking me to come pick up a new set of keys. There were several incidents afterward, and we decided to reduce the lobby hours from 9 pm to 6 pm and were now closed on weekends. After that, I rarely checked the mailbox. It's probably been at least three months since I've checked for mail. It doesn't help that the lobby hours have changed, and getting to the box is somewhat of a pain in the ass.

Before You Commit to a Virtual Mailbox, Please Don't Make This Mistake

I didn't give the location much thought when renting a PO box. I figured I would be fine if I could get to it on the weekends. I also, for whatever reason, thought that the USPS one was better. I kept telling myself, “Please don't bother with the UPS Store, Postal Annex, or any other providers because it might be more of a hassle to set up and check mail.” I had no idea what the fuck I was talking about. Despite working from home for years, I also hadn't considered how often I traveled. I say this as I look at my unpacked suitcase and gear backpacks.

The idea of being married to one location makes me sick. Even writing that didn't make sense to me, considering I just told you how often I travel, and yet I had a piece of my life firmly planted in a physical mailbox. This is what autopilot looks like. I already have enough shit on my plate, and what I bought myself was a problem by not being completely honest with my current business needs. I waited too long to find other viable solutions because I didn't want to deal with the reality of it all. I tend to stick with things like software and systems until I have no use for them.

This time, I believe the hassle of setting up the initial PO box at the post office kept me from closing it, not to mention the hours of research involved in finding a better solution. However, it was time.

It took me less than one minute to close my PO box online. Two clicks and a disclaimer. Because I canceled my account before the fourth month, USPS refunded me 50% of the cost. I now have 10 days to pick up any remaining mail and hand over the keys. 

I'll learn nothing from this. 🦄 💅🏼

The Missing Piece of My Virtual Office Setup and Maybe Yours, Too

For starters, I needed a replacement for my PO box ASAP. My renewal was set for July at $96 for 6 months (the initial cost was $82). I also needed a Bay Area address. Regardless of where I am in the world, the Bay Area is home. In a SHTF (shit hits the fan) situation, I need to have an address where I could continue doing business while traveling (including extended stay travel). I don't sell physical products, which gave me an advantage when looking for mailbox locations. I also needed a way to process mail and packages with minimal effort. Lastly, I needed a mailbox address to receive my bills and anything else from my business, without all the drama from the State of California vs. USPS PO box situation.

I needed to do this quickly and online.

Looking at my current business needs and what I see for the foreseeable future, a virtual mailbox would be more than enough. I have a separate phone number through GoDaddy Conversations (formerly GoDaddy SmartLine) and a fax number through Cocofax. Yes, a fax number.

It seems outdated in 2025, but I've said it before: people still fax. I'm looking at you, California Franchise Tax Board.

How I Chose My Anytime Mailbox Location

Besides being in the Bay Area proper, I needed to find a location I wouldn't loathe going to should I need to pick up mail. Of course, the point of getting the virtual mailbox was to avoid going to a physical location, but I still needed the option. I wanted to choose a tech hub city. My stomping grounds are the East Bay. For those unfamiliar with the San Francisco Bay Area, that's on the other side of the San Francisco Bay: Oakland, Alameda, etc. I noted where I am likely to go and which places I avoid. I'm rarely in San Jose, and have you seen the recent toll charges for crossing the bridge into San Francisco? oOF. While most locations closed at 6 p.m., safety was also a priority. How's the parking situation? Nobody wants to fight for a space in a Trader Joe's shopping center.

After narrowing it down to three top rated locations, I checked the reviews on Yelp and searched Google Maps street view. Many virtual mailboxes in the US are located within a Postal Annex, UPS Store, FedEx Office, or small mom-and-pop shop usually found in a shopping center. What are the other businesses around it? Does that even matter to you?

I believe I found it right smack in the middle of everywhere I want to be.

What To Expect When You're Setting Up Anytime Mailbox for the First Time

After you've decided on your virtual mailbox location and paid the deposit fee set by the location (mine was $9.99), you'll receive an email with instructions on filling out the USPS Form 1583. The form must be completed and notarized to verify your identity and authorize your chosen location to handle your mail and packages. This process helps ensure the security of your mail.

If you skip this step, your virtual mailbox will not be activated, and you will not receive mail at your chosen location. 

You need to provide two identification forms: one must be a primary photo ID (e.g. Passport, School ID, Driver's License or State or Federal Issued ID Card etc.), and the other must confirm your current address (e.g. Current Lease/Mortgage or Insurance Policy, Vehicle Registration Card, Voter Card, Driver's License or State or Federal Issued ID card with your address on it). 

These need to be two different ID forms. For example, you can't use your Driver's License twice. 

I used my U.S. passport to verify my identity and my California Driver's License to verify my residence. 

Online Notarization Process with Notarize by Proof

Anytime Mailbox has simplified the notarization process for USPS Form 1583 by providing online notary services. Just log in to your Anytime Mailbox account, follow the verification steps, and complete the notary process quickly and easily in just a few minutes!

Before starting the verification process, ensure you have your valid driver's license with the address intended for USPS Form 1583. It will be needed during the online notary process (Notarize by Proof).

Do this on a desktop/laptop. Use your phone for uploading and scanning the docs. 
Thank me later. 

Once logged in, you will be asked a few questions, making it feel like you're filling out a passport form. Please double-check everything before continuing. I didn't see a way to go back to correct information. When you are done, the answers will auto-populate on the form. Before you finish the form, grab the documents you set aside: a primary photo ID and the other to confirm your current address.

A screen will pop up asking you to upload your documents. I suggest you have your mobile phone ready because it's easier to scan your documents this way. Scan the QR code on the screen to begin. Follow the instructions. You must take two front and back pictures for each identification form. After Proof has verified your documents, you can schedule an online notary appointment.

Check your camera and mic. Allow both to be used on the browser. You have to be on video. I know—my condolences. Choose the next available one and stay online. This will go by fast. Make sure your lighting is good, too.

My appointment was with a notary in Texas. The video call was recorded, and they verified that my information was accurate. One minute and done. That includes the part where I fussed with my mic because of the Logitech webcam settings. Remember what I said?

Look for the confirmation emails. I received one from Anytime Mailbox and one from Postal Annex.

Start Using Your Anytime Mailbox Virtual Mailbox

According to Anytime Mailbox, your application can take 2-3 business days to process. I received this information in an email at 4:57 a.m., shortly after getting the documents notarized, and my virtual mailbox was ready to use at 11:06 a.m. By lunch, I had updated my address everywhere and closed the PO box.

USPS Form 1583 is not the same as a USPS mail forwarding form. 

It is not intended for mail forwarding, and the Commercial Mail Receiving Agency (CMRA) operator will not forward your mail. Instead, USPS Form 1583 authorizes the CMRA to receive mail on your behalf at the designated address.

If you wish to have USPS forward your mail, you will need to fill out a separate Change of Address form. You can download it through the Official USPS® Change of Address service.

Why I Chose Anytime Mailbox instead of iPostal1 or Other Virtual Mailbox Services

Countless YouTube videos and Reddit posts later, I kept running into the same complaints:

• Some locations were shady (e.g., fees started to increase), but this was the case across the board, so I don't hold it against the CMRAs.
• iPostal1 support sucks.
• The iPostal1 app is clunky.
• Traveling Mailbox doesn't have a pickup option.
• All other addresses are considered premium unless you use the Traveling Mailbox NC address.
• Traveling Mailbox is for US addresses only.

The bottom line is they all do the same thing, and you have to shop for one that fits your needs. Across the board, the consensus was that the location was more important than the virtual mailbox service provider. Many of the mailbox locations are available on all platforms. You'll start to see a pattern. Even though iPostal1 had the most available locations in California, I couldn't gauge if a mailbox location was good. Granted, I still had to do my due diligence and check reviews; adding that feature would have been nice.

This is my first time using a virtual mailbox and the Anytime Mailbox service, so I have nothing else to compare it to besides a traditional USPS PO box. I will update you as changes happen.

Anytime Mailbox First Impressions: Day One

I haven't received mail yet because, as of writing this post, the account is probably less than 24 hours old. Maybe I should send myself a letter or something to test it.

However, a few things have already irked me. The website needed a way to filter through locations by features and services. I should have been able to look for mailbox locations that offered check deposits. I ended up with a location that doesn't. I guess I will deal with that if it becomes an issue later.

The other filter that desperately needs to be more options is international forwarding. I can't check if a location ships mail and packages internationally to all available international locations.

I did not have the option of just clicking a button to upgrade or downgrade my plan. This may be more of how Commercial Mail Receiving Agency operators are set up. I don't know. It's not a deal breaker, but it isn't very pleasant. In that same vein, I'd have to start the process again to change mailbox locations.

The app is barebones, but works.

Under Settings, you can add more forwarding addresses. Yes, that means you'll have to prove residence there, too. Notifications are basic SMS. Type in your phone number, and you're good to go. The security settings are as follows: Keep my logged in. Use Face ID. *merp*

Help has the virtual mailbox support contact information: an email, phone number, and a link to Anytime Mailbox's knowledge base.

Conclusion

Selecting the right virtual mailbox service can greatly improve your mail management process, offering peace of mind, especially for online business owners. For individuals running an online business, a virtual mailbox ensures that you remain organized and focused on your work without the inconvenience of physical mail disruptions. Additionally, you can enjoy the freedom to travel while easily managing your mail anywhere.

To select a service that aligns with your specific needs, it's important to evaluate your requirements thoroughly. Start by researching the various options on the market, considering key factors such as security features, pricing structures (don't forget the overage fees if applicable), and the quality of customer support.

While making an informed decision is essential, it's equally important to avoid analysis paralysis. Sometimes, taking the leap and choosing a virtual mailbox provider to test out is the best approach. After all, you can't worry about whether it will work out until you receive your first piece of mail!

You can always try again.

Enjoy the convenience and security of efficient mail handling, freeing up time for more important elements of your life and business. With everything organized and accessible, you’ll experience a newfound sense of relief and satisfaction, confident that your mail is managed seamlessly at home or on the move.

Alright, it's time for me to pack!

THIS SITE USES AFFILIATE LINKS. THERE’S NO EXTRA COST TO YOU, BUT I RECEIVE A SMALL COMMISSION WHEN YOU USE THEM.

PIN ME!